"Once you eliminate the impossible, whatever remains, no matter how improbable, must be the
truth." – Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, from The Sign of the Four.
It’s the kind of trick that Harry Houdini would have had problems
pulling off. Yes, that Houdini, whom according to stories could slip out of the
tightest handcuffs, crack open a safe from the inside, safely survive falling
into open water in a frozen river… Miracles? It may seem so, but for Harry it
was all part of the show.
No one really knows how he pulled off all those escapes. Some of them,
like escaping from a strait jacket, seem in credible. Sure, it was only a show,
but it was an amazing show. It was a stupendous show. And yet, deep down
inside, we somehow know it was a trick of some sort. Whether he was double
jointed, or had extremely thin hands, or just plain knew more about things than
most of us, we understood it was a show and that Houdini was a mast showman.
But some of the things that have been happening lately just defy logic.
Take for instance the case of Victor White III who died in a Louisiana hospital
from a “self-inflicted” gunshot wound. Sure suicides happen all the time, so
why would just another suicide create suspicion?
Well, as with anything in life, the devil, as they say, is in the
details. In my experience, suicide is strictly a personal thing. No matter how
the deed is done, it’s typically something the perpetrator/victim does alone.
Alone meaning with no one else around. But that may not have been the case with
Mr. White.
Mr. White was walking down the street when a New Iberia sheriff’s
cruiser pulled up and stopped him. The sheriff was responding to a call about a
fight some six blocks from where Mr. White was stopped. Although White and his
friend Isaiah Lewis were not involved in the fight, the deputy stopped them and
searched them. He searched hard enough to find a small quantity of marijuana on
White and subsequently cuffed him behind his back and put him in the police
car.
The deputy involved, Corporal Justin Orvis, had no real description to
go on when he made the stop, just that the men were black and that one might
have had a gun. One would think at that point, if you searched a suspect
suspected of being armed, you might want to try to find a gun. But nonetheless
there was no gun reported in the initial report.
Somehow, apparently, White ended up getting shot in the chest. The
initial report suggested the shot hit White in the back. But the coroner’s
report showed the bullet entering from the right front.
One might suspect that such an incident, a handcuffed suspect shot in
the chest, would be cause for suspicion of murder. But the state moved forward
with its investigation, waiting on the results of the autopsy. Those results
have raised some eyebrows in Louisiana. The coroner’s report listed the cause
of death as suicide.
Suicide? Really?
It seems to me that holding a pistol at such an angle that one could
hit oneself in the chest would be problematic for someone with their hands
cuffed behind their back. Holding a pistol at all with your hands cuffed behind
your back, I would think, would be pretty hard to do. And so I think, well
maybe this is an isolated incident.
Not so says Google. According to the Internet search engine, there are
at least two other similar acts of suicide:
- Chavis Carter, 21, was shot in the head while handcuffed in the back of a police car in Jonesboro, Arkansas
- Tyree Woodson, 38, apparently snuck a gun past Baltimore police and into a holding cell, and then shot himself while handcuffed in the bathroom.
It seems odd that such a thing could happen even once. But to have
happened at least three times, and I am almost certain there are more instances
that just haven’t been brought to light, just doesn’t make sense.
When incidents like this happen, and apparently with some regularity,
it makes it easy to understand why some people find it hard to trust the
authorities. How Mr White’s case ends up is yet to be determined. But it would
be very hard for a suicide to throw away the weapon of choice, especially while
handcuffed inside a police cruiser. A simple test for gunshot residue on the
hands and finger prints on the weapon may have more to say about this than a
coroner’s report that seems illogical on its face.